Cover page for the PFS ERFT (Erosion Risk Forest Transition) Standard, a draft consultation document dated November 20, 2026.

Live Consultation

The Consultation on the draft PFS ERFT Standard V1 (Erosion Risk Forest Transition) is open from 20th November to 5.00 pm NZT on 20th December 2026.

Cover page for the PFS Certification Limited Commentary on the PFS ERFT Standard v1, a draft for consultation from November 20 to December 20, 2026.
Cover page of the PFS Certification Limited Operations Manual for the PFS ERFT Standard v1, marked Draft for Consultation.

For an overview of how the Standard works, see ‘How the ERFT Standard works’ in the Commentary.

Consultation: how to comment

The consultation runs from 20 November 2026 to 20 December 2026. Comments are made on the comment form. We particularly want comment on these questions:

  1. Is charging the Project only with the carbon released beyond what the failing stand would have lost anyway the right approach to the felling (ERFT9)?

  2. Where the transition is the price of IFM credits, is limiting ERFT credits to any shortfall the right approach (ERFT13.3)?

  3. Is a costed harvest-economics statement, independently tested, the right safeguard for Associated Land, in place of any limit on its area (ERFT5.3 to ERFT5.3D)?

Please submit the completed comment form and add any attachments or email: info@pfs-carbonstandard.com

What makes a comment useful

Please give, for each point:

  1. the clause of the Standard or Schedule you are commenting on;

  2. the problem — what you think is wrong or uncertain;

  3. the change you propose;

  4. the evidence — a dataset, study or record, with enough detail for us to find it; and

  5. the climate cost — where your comment gives weight to an environmental or social goal, the climate cost of what you propose, including the cost to future generations, and why it is justified (A11.9).

A comment that proposes a change without evidence is recorded and considered, but it cannot be weighed in the same way as one that shows its working.

How evidence is weighed

We apply two principles the Standard already uses for hazard data. Evidence specific to the species and region is preferred to evidence that is not (F5.4.4). And a rate must pair a numerator and a denominator describing the same population (F5.4.1, S7.19). Subject to those, we weigh evidence in this order:

  1. published datasets and peer-reviewed studies of New Zealand forests;

  2. peer-reviewed international studies, with their applicability to New Zealand conditions shown;

  3. reports of Scion Research, other parts of Crown Research Institutes and government agencies;

  4. other published reports; and

  5. expert opinion, with the reasons for it stated.

Where two sources conflict, we will say which we prefer and why (A14.8).

We particularly welcome comment on whether the counterfactual is the right measure. The counterfactual is the declining stand (ERFT11).   

Other comments

We also welcome comment on governance, environmental and social matters, and on the Standard's approach generally. These are recorded, considered, and answered in the published response.

What happens to your comment

You will receive an acknowledgement.

At the close of the consultation, every submission is published, redacted only for private information, with a summary of the issues and PFS's response to each, including where a submission was not accepted and why (A11.3). Please tell us if you do not want your name published.

Submissions from Validation and Verification Bodies are addressed expressly in the published response, with reasons where they are not adopted (A11.7).

PFS may change the draft Standard and the Commentary before the Standard is adopted, whether or not the change was raised in a submission, and need not consult again on a change it makes. After adoption, any change to the Standard is made through its review process (A14).

We aim to publish the response within 90 days of the close.

Comment form

The comment form is completed and submitted online, on the consultation page of the PFS website (www.pfs-carbonstandard.com). Submissions are received online (A11.6). Fields marked with an asterisk (*) must be completed, and the others are optional. Please submit a separate form for each clause or Schedule you comment on, so that each point can be recorded and answered. Supporting data and documents can be attached to the form. A submission must be received by 5pm New Zealand time on 20th December 2026.

Comment Form